history principles practice stories, books, media discussion forum organizations resources
zenguide.com logo
 
Thursday Oct 02 2014 08:28AM ET
º login º register º email º guestbook º printer friendly
grey dot
  The Buddha once taught the Bhikkhus about the All:

"I will teach you the All. Listen closely. What is the All? It is eye and visible object,
ear and sound, nose and scent, tongue and taste, body and feelings, mind and ideas.
... continue...

z
.
e
.
n
menu left history menu spacer principles menu spacer practice menu spacer zen media menu spacer discussion forum menu spacer organization directory menu spacer resources  
login
  DISCUSSION FORUM
» topic list   » start a new topic   » my tracked topics   » view topic
grey dot

horizontal line
→→→→ vertical line TOPIC: MORAL JUDGEMENTS.
vertical line Posted on Mar.23.2007 @ 06:57AM EDT by stephen

March 21, 2007

Study Finds Brain Injury Changes Moral Judgment By BENEDICT CAREY

Damage to an area of the brain behind the forehead, inches behind the eyes, transforms the way people make moral judgments in life-or-death situations, scientists are reporting today. In a new study, people with this rare injury expressed increased willingness to kill or harm another person if doing so would save others' lives.

The findings are the most direct evidence to date that humans’ native revulsion for hurting others relies on a part of neural anatomy, one that likely evolved before the brain regions responsible for analysis and planning.

The researchers emphasize that the study was small and that the moral decisions were hypothetical; the results cannot predict how people with or without brain injuries will act in real life-or-death situations. Yet the findings, published online by the journal Nature, confirm the central role of the damaged region - the ventromedial prefrontal cortex, which is thought to generate social emotions, like compassion.

Previous studies showed that this region was active during moral decision-making, and that damage to it and neighboring areas from severe dementia affected moral judgments. The new study seals the case by demonstrating that a very specific kind of emotion-based judgment is altered when the region is offline. In extreme circumstances, people with the injury will even endorse suffocating an infant if that would save more lives.

"I think it’s very convincing now that there are at least two systems working when we make moral judgments," said Joshua Greene, a psychologist at Harvard who was not involved in the study. "There’s an emotional system that depends on this specific part of the brain, and another system that performs more utilitarian cost-benefit analyses which in these people is clearly intact."

The finding could have implications for legal cases. Jurors have reduced sentences based on brain-imaging results, and experts say that any evidence of damage to this ventromedial area could sway judgments of moral competency in some cases.

The new study focused on six patients who had suffered very specific damage to the ventromedial area from an aneurysm or a tumor. The cortex is the thick outer wrapping of the brain, where the distinctly human, mostly conscious functions of thinking and language reside. The term ventral means underneath, and medial means near the middle. The area in adults is about the size of a child’s fist.

People with this injury can be lucid, easygoing, talkative and intelligent, but blind to subtle social cues, making them socially awkward. They also have some of the same moral instincts that others do.

The researchers, from the University of Iowa and other institutions, had them respond to several moral challenges. In one, they had to decide whether to divert a runaway boxcar that was about to kill a group of five workmen. To save they workers they would have to flip a switch, sending the car hurtling into another man, who would be killed.

They strongly favored flipping the switch, just as group of people without injuries did. A third group, with brain damage that did not affect the ventromedial cortex, made the same decision.

All three groups also strongly rejected doing harm to others in situations that were not a matter of trading one certain death for another. They would not send a daughter to work in the pornography industry to fend off crushing poverty, or kill an infant they felt they could not care for.

But a large difference in the participants’ decisions emerged when there was no switch to flip - when they had to choose between taking direct action to kill or harm someone (pushing him in front of the runaway boxcar, for example) and serving a greater good.

Those with ventromedial injuries were about twice as likely as the other participants to say they would push someone in front of the train (if that was the only option), or to poison someone with AIDS who was bent on infecting others, or suffocate a baby whose crying would reveal to enemy soldiers where the subject and family and friends were hiding.

"The difference was very clear, for all of the ventromedial patients," said Dr. Michael Koenigs, a neuroscientist at the National Institutes of Health who led the study while at the University of Iowa. After repeatedly endorsing killing in these high-conflict situations, he added, one patient told him, "Jeez, I’ve turned into a killer."

The other authors were Dr. Daniel Tranel of Iowa and neuroscientists from Harvard, the University of Southern California and the California Institute of Technology.

The ventromedial area is a primitive part of the cortex that appears to have evolved to help humans and other mammals navigate social interactions. The area has connections to deeper, unconscious regions like the brain stem, which transmit physical sensations of attraction or discomfort; and the amygdala, a gumdrop of neural tissue that registers threats, social and otherwise. The ventromedial area integrates these signals with others from the cortex, including emotional memories, to help generate familiar social reactions.

"This area when it’s working will give rise to social emotions that we can feel, like embarrassment, guilt, compassion that are critical to guiding our social behavior," said Dr. Antonio Damasio, a co-author and a neuroscientist at the Brain and Creativity Institute at U.S.C. These sensations in effect put a finger on the brain’s conscious, cost-benefit scale weighing moral dilemmas, Dr. Damasio argues, creating a tension that even trained snipers can feel when having to pull the trigger on an enemy.

This tension between cost-benefit calculations and instinctive emotion in part reflects the brain’s continuing adjustment to the vast social changes that have occurred since the ventromedial area first took shape. The ventromedial area most likely adapted to assist the brain in making snap moral decisions in small kin groups- to spare a valuable group member’s life after a fight, for instance. As human communities became larger and increasingly complex, so did the cortical structures involved in parsing ethical dilemmas. But the more primitive ventromedial area continued to anchor it with emotional insistence an ancient principle: respect for the life of another human being.

"A nice way to think about it," Dr. Damasio said, "is that we have this emotional system built in, and over the years culture has worked on it to make it even better."

Copyright 2007 The New York Times Company


Go to Latest Reply   Reply to this Topic   Email stephen
horizontal line
 
horizontal line
Reply from whatzen
Mar.23.2007
10:23AM EDT 
Email whatzen
vertical line

Yeah, you gotta watch those babies.

Hey, I wonder if that could be related to the frontal brain that receives damage after long term meth use? Those people can get awfully kooky. I know, I used to be one of them. Thank goodness I didnt need that part of my brain anyway!

vertical line Quote & Reply   Post Reply 70024
horizontal line
 
horizontal line
Reply from lehish
Mar.23.2007
11:51AM EDT 
Email lehish
vertical line

H what U zen G

vertical line Quote & Reply   Post Reply 70050
horizontal line
 
horizontal line
Reply from whatzen
Mar.23.2007
11:54AM EDT 
Email whatzen
vertical line Quote: "

H what U zen G

"
.........

"
.........

:-) H leh U ish G

vertical line Quote & Reply   Post Reply 70051
horizontal line
 
horizontal line
Reply from lehish
Mar.23.2007
07:08PM EDT 
Email lehish
vertical line :)
vertical line Quote & Reply   Post Reply 70096
horizontal line
 
horizontal line
Reply from 77 zen ror
Mar.23.2007
08:07PM EDT 
Email 77 zen ror
vertical line The mine is a tearbele thing to wast. Show it love & compassion. Be good to your self& others. LOVE RORY
vertical line Quote & Reply   Post Reply 70098
horizontal line
 
horizontal line
Reply from amylim
Mar.24.2007
07:05AM EDT 
Email amylim
vertical line

Science Tried Explaining People's-minds Have Ended Nowhere

With Metta

vertical line Quote & Reply   Post Reply 70103
horizontal line
 
horizontal line
Reply from Lionel
Mar.24.2007
07:50AM EDT 
Email Lionel
vertical line Quote: "

Science Tried Explaining People's-minds Have Ended Nowhere

With Metta

"
.........

"
.........

Yup..., I know nothing about science, but at the same time science is the only common ground for mankinds knowlegeable & manageable for common interest/commitment or perhaps come close to it, unless there's coming up with a common system/religion/teaching of AWARENESS! I think we have a nice & wonderful garden here, 3 cheers~~~

Perhaps brain is just the finest tools like other organs...

But where is our arising mind or pure mind? Some say in every atom, some say in the brain, some say everywhere or nowhere?

vertical line Quote & Reply   Post Reply 70104
horizontal line
 
horizontal line
Reply from amylim
Mar.24.2007
08:22AM EDT 
Email amylim
vertical line Quote: "Quote: "

Science Tried Explaining People's-minds Have Ended Nowhere

With Metta

"
.........

"
.........

Yup..., I know nothing about science, but at the same time science is the only common ground for mankinds knowlegeable & manageable for common interest/commitment or perhaps come close to it, unless there's coming up with a common system/religion/teaching of AWARENESS! I think we have a nice & wonderful garden here, 3 cheers~~~

Perhaps brain is just the finest tools like other organs...

But where is our arising mind or pure mind? Some say in every atom, some say in the brain, some say everywhere or nowhere?

"
.........

"
.........

Living In One's Nature Explains Life

With Metta

vertical line Quote & Reply   Post Reply 70107
horizontal line
 
horizontal line
Reply from ______
Mar.24.2007
10:58AM EDT 
vertical line Yeah, and you have to watch that pure mind, or else it'll cocoon ya! Zap! Just like that! And yep, before you can say "Private gentleman's club", Wham! job done - you're the first banana on your street to come home with doughnuts for balls in a box.
vertical line Quote & Reply   Post Reply 70112
horizontal line
 
horizontal line
Reply from ______
Mar.24.2007
11:20AM EDT 
vertical line Will ya look it that? Flip my switch and compassion is a social emotion. My willingness has increased out of damage, yeah in this company of narcissi, I'm borderline personality disorder which is a good thing.
vertical line Quote & Reply   Post Reply 70114
horizontal line
 
horizontal line
Reply from 77 zen ror
Mar.24.2007
08:30PM EDT 
Email 77 zen ror
vertical line Life is a good thing. Enjoy it.
vertical line Quote & Reply   Post Reply 70130
horizontal line
 
horizontal line
Reply from ______
Mar.25.2007
06:37AM EDT 
vertical line I be. I am.
vertical line Quote & Reply   Post Reply 70133
horizontal line
 
horizontal line
Reply from whatzen
Mar.26.2007
01:24PM EDT 
Email whatzen
vertical line sunny breezy furry tree
vertical line Quote & Reply   Post Reply 70212
horizontal line
 
horizontal line
Reply from lehish
Mar.26.2007
01:27PM EDT 
Email lehish
vertical line :)
vertical line Quote & Reply   Post Reply 70213
horizontal line
 
Back To Topic List   Go to Top of Page

 



SUPPORT ZENGUIDE.COM
If you are planning on purchasing any product from amazon.com, you can help us out by using the search box to the right or by clicking on this link to begin shopping.


Purchase posters, art prints, media (music CD & DVD)

buy this SITASAMVARA
by
Puchase this Item
More Art Prints & Media
Zen & Buddhism books
 
 
d
.
i
.
s
.
c
.
u
.
s
.
s
.
i
.
o
.
n
.

.
f
.
o
.
r
.
u
.
m
.
Copyright © 1999 - 2014 zenguide.com - All rights reserved. °