 |
| →→→→ |
 |
TOPIC: IDENTITY AND KARMA |
|
|
 |
Posted on Dec.02.2012 @ 09:38AM EDT by Julito
I would like to ask about identity.
I know about anatta, there's no individual soul, OK. In non-dualism the "soul" is just "god" but in Buddhism there's no soul.
So, correct me if I'm wrong, in rebirth a part of our mind goes to a new body in a new land depending of Karma. We are responsible of what we do with our mind and our body during our life so, are we our mind and our body according to Buddhism? Or are they just a part of us?
I can watch my own body and I can watch my own mind, what is the "observer"? Is it me?
Thank you very much for your answers.
Julito
|
|
↓Go to Latest Reply
|
→Reply to this Topic
→Email Julito
|
 |
| |
 |
|
Reply from QuantumZen
Dec.02.2012
01:05PM EDT
→Email QuantumZen
|
 |
Universe is not self aware. As knife doesn't cut itself and light doesn't shine on itself, atman (the one that is everything) doesn't know/perceive itself as neither everyhing there is, nor only thing there is. We are it and yet we are a part of it. As an acorn is everything that is to oak and yet merely a small seed.
We can imagine to have minds, distinct bodies and many other polarized phenomenom (we choose to do it because of social comfort). But there is no we to begin with. You are a drop in the ocean. Which one are you? ;) |
|
|
 |
→Quote & Reply
→Post Reply
148261
|
 |
| |
 |
|
Reply from sit_teh
Dec.02.2012
02:08PM EDT
→Email sit_teh
|
 |
Being is & that is that. |
|
|
 |
→Quote & Reply
→Post Reply
148262
|
 |
| |
 |
|
Reply from leoj99
Dec.02.2012
02:29PM EDT
|
 |
"I can watch my own body and I can watch my own mind, what is the "observer"? Is it me?"
If someone you are or you are not... you still have to find out yourself if it is true or not..
|
|
|
 |
→Quote & Reply
→Post Reply
148263
|
 |
| |
 |
|
Reply from leoj99
Dec.02.2012
02:30PM EDT
|
 |
Quote: ""I can watch my own body and I can watch my own mind, what is the "observer"? Is it me?"
If someone you are or you are not... you still have to find out yourself if it is true or not..
" .........
If someone say you are .....
|
|
|
 |
→Quote & Reply
→Post Reply
148264
|
 |
| |
 |
|
Reply from sit_teh
Dec.02.2012
02:48PM EDT
→Email sit_teh
|
 |
Look at the motive and look at the person just as one is. |
|
|
 |
→Quote & Reply
→Post Reply
148268
|
 |
| |
 |
|
Reply from Sam Hardy
Dec.02.2012
04:16PM EDT
→Email Sam Hardy
|
 |
You say ‘I’ can watch my own body and 'I'
can watch my own mind, so who or what is the ‘I’ that is observing or
watching? This is something that each of us has to find
out for ourselves in our own experience of meditation.
We can read all the sacred literature
and teachings in the world that will tell us what this ‘I’ is and use different
words to describe it, among which are ‘self’, ‘God’ ‘ever-present awareness’ ‘ever-present
Big mind’ and ‘Buddha nature’ etc. But when it comes down to it, I don’t think
it means a great deal until we have realized in our deepest selves what this
‘I’ is that seems to be neither our body, our mind or the thoughts that arise
in our mind.
Sorry if you don’t find this answer helpful. As I said, there’s no shortage of books
that go into and explain our ‘real self’ or ‘our true nature’ but as I say, it
is something that you have to find out for yourself rather than learn from
reading what someone else has said or written, however enlightened and
self-realized these other people may be and doubtless are or were.
|
|
|
 |
→Quote & Reply
→Post Reply
148272
|
 |
| |
 |
|
Reply from leoj99
Dec.02.2012
05:48PM EDT
|
 |
I think if you find the small "i" or the no "i".. instead of the capital "I" the big "I" you have a direct clue to it.. |
|
|
 |
→Quote & Reply
→Post Reply
148274
|
 |
| |
 |
|
Reply from leoj99
Dec.02.2012
05:56PM EDT
|
 |
Odnalezienie siebie (15) |
|
|
 |
→Quote & Reply
→Post Reply
148275
|
 |
| |
 |
|
Reply from Joe Chip
Dec.03.2012
08:48AM EDT
|
 |
The big wheel keeps on turning, rolling on, so mind your toes, they're not yours. |
|
|
 |
→Quote & Reply
→Post Reply
148293
|
 |
| |
 |
|
Reply from Avisitor
Dec.03.2012
09:38AM EDT
→Email Avisitor
|
 |
impermanence (anicca), suffering (dukkha), non-self (anatta) are the three marks of existence. Impermanence is change. All things made up of aggregates will change. Suffering is due to craving and ignorance. Anatta is non self or no self.
Thinking of reincarnation and no self ?? What is it that reincarnates?? Your body and mind are aggregates so they will go through change and will suffer but there is no self to suffer or change ... hahaha
Are we our mind and our body according to Buddhism? Or are they just a part of us? No ... we are not our mind nor are we our body ... haha Those things are aggregates. Looking into yourself ... you will find emptiness and everything. Take the time to answer your question yourself.
|
|
|
 |
→Quote & Reply
→Post Reply
148298
|
 |
| |
 |
|
Reply from Joe Chip
Dec.03.2012
09:52AM EDT
|
 |
Your aggregate problems arise from your separation of mind and body. |
|
|
 |
→Quote & Reply
→Post Reply
148300
|
 |
| |
 |
|
Reply from Julito
Dec.04.2012
03:37AM EDT
→Email Julito
|
 |
Quote: "Universe is not self aware. As knife doesn't cut itself and light doesn't shine on itself, atman (the one that is everything) doesn't know/perceive itself as neither everyhing there is, nor only thing there is. We are it and yet we are a part of it. As an acorn is everything that is to oak and yet merely a small seed.
We can imagine to have minds, distinct bodies and many other polarized phenomenom (we choose to do it because of social comfort). But there is no we to begin with. You are a drop in the ocean. Which one are you? ;)" .........
So if Atman isn't self aware, ilumination isn't like a self awarening, is it?
Thank you all for your answers, btw! Thank you very much :-)
|
|
|
 |
→Quote & Reply
→Post Reply
148325
|
 |
| |
 |
|
Reply from leoj99
Dec.04.2012
03:58AM EDT
|
 |
Your identity is your conditioning. What you have learned of what you are. And that identity is your karma, the cause of all your suffering. |
|
|
 |
→Quote & Reply
→Post Reply
148327
|
 |
| |
 |
|
Reply from Sam Hardy
Dec.04.2012
05:55AM EDT
→Email Sam Hardy
|
 |
Quote: "Quote: "Universe is not self aware. As knife doesn't cut itself and light doesn't shine on itself, atman (the one that is everything) doesn't know/perceive itself as neither everyhing there is, nor only thing there is. We are it and yet we are a part of it. As an acorn is everything that is to oak and yet merely a small seed.
We can imagine to have minds, distinct bodies and many other polarized phenomenom (we choose to do it because of social comfort). But there is no we to begin with. You are a drop in the ocean. Which one are you? ;)" .........
So if Atman isn't self aware, ilumination isn't like a self awarening, is it?
Thank you all for your answers, btw! Thank you very much :-) " .........
Depends what you mean by illumination. It doesn't make
sense to say that illumination is not illumination or that self-awakening is
not self-awakening - even in Zen.
And the universe is self aware and conscious and we as human beings can
and do become aware that we are aware.
We are a part of the universe, stardust if you like, that has become
conscious and self-conscious. Otherwise
it wouldn’t be possible to observe our own thoughts and be aware that these
thoughts are not ‘me’, that they arise in consciousness and then vanish out of
consciousness.
A knife may not be able to cut itself (unless you break it
in two), but consciousness is not exactly the same thing as a knife – a knife
is a physical object and consciousness is not a physical object or even a thing
at all (despite nonduality and emptiness).
And as such it can think and
speculate on the nature of consciousness, that is, on its own nature.
Btw there's no such word as 'self-awarening'.
Self-awareness yes. Self-awakening yes. 'Self-awarening' no. Maybe you're trying to
coin a new word or concept. It’s just not clear what it’s supposed to mean. Perhaps
‘becoming self-aware’?
Unfortunately, words need to be used as carefully and accurately as possible in
a forum like this because we don't have the facility of expressing ourselves
through physical action, gestures or body language here. Otherwise we're just guessing what someone
else is trying to say.
Zen has become synonymous with or infamous for accommodating
self-contradiction and paradox but there’s a limit.
Typical airy fairy pseudo Zen talk like, for example, ‘the
pants you’re wearing and not wearing’ is nonsense. You’re either wearing a pair of pants or you’re
not (unless perhaps they’re around your knees or ankles). If you don’t believe me, the next time you go
to work, go without any pants on and see if there’s anyone who doesn’t notice you’re not wearing any pants. (And you won’t
get round it by wearing a skirt instead.)
Zen is also about being real and down to earth and practical
and commonsensical.
I like talking nonsense myself as must be clear from some if
not all of my posts. lol. However I try
to be aware that I am talking nonsense when I’m doing it.
If anyone thinks I am talking nonsense now, please feel free
to let me know and I’ll seek to mend the error of my ways.
|
|
|
 |
→Quote & Reply
→Post Reply
148328
|
 |
| |
 |
|
Reply from Avisitor
Dec.04.2012
09:24AM EDT
→Email Avisitor
|
 |
Quote: "Quote: "Universe is not self aware. As knife doesn't cut itself and light doesn't shine on itself, atman (the one that is everything) doesn't know/perceive itself as neither everyhing there is, nor only thing there is. We are it and yet we are a part of it. As an acorn is everything that is to oak and yet merely a small seed.
We can imagine to have minds, distinct bodies and many other polarized phenomenom (we choose to do it because of social comfort). But there is no we to begin with. You are a drop in the ocean. Which one are you? ;)" .........
So if Atman isn't self aware, ilumination isn't like a self awarening, is it?
Thank you all for your answers, btw! Thank you very much :-) " ......... No, illumination isn't like self awakening. You can illuminate concepts to the point of clarity, conciseness But, you can not illuminate self awareness ... you can only be self awareness, self awakening. Practice more and these things will illuminate themselves ... hahaha
|
|
|
 |
→Quote & Reply
→Post Reply
148329
|
 |
| |
 |
|
Reply from leoj99
Dec.04.2012
11:32AM EDT
|
 |
I can see that it seems you are very clever. Illumination is there is light or you can see the light. If you can see the light I think that is the same as being aware or even awakening. Consciousness is nothing but your conditioning. So once you see this conditioning there is illumination, awareness, awakening... |
|
|
 |
→Quote & Reply
→Post Reply
148334
|
 |
| |
 |
|
Reply from Avisitor
Dec.04.2012
04:01PM EDT
→Email Avisitor
|
 |
Quote: "I can see that it seems you are very clever. Illumination is there is light or you can see the light. If you can see the light I think that is the same as being aware or even awakening. Consciousness is nothing but your conditioning. So once you see this conditioning there is illumination, awareness, awakening...
" .........
Illumination and awareness are not the same. Don't confuse the two ... hahaha
|
|
|
 |
→Quote & Reply
→Post Reply
148335
|
 |
| |
 |
|
Reply from sit_teh
Dec.04.2012
07:39PM EDT
→Email sit_teh
|
 |
Quote: "Quote: "I can see that it seems you are very clever. Illumination is there is light or you can see the light. If you can see the light I think that is the same as being aware or even awakening. Consciousness is nothing but your conditioning. So once you see this conditioning there is illumination, awareness, awakening...
" .........
Illumination and awareness are not the same. Don't confuse the two ... hahaha " .........
I see 'that is that.' |
|
|
 |
→Quote & Reply
→Post Reply
148336
|
 |
| |
 |
|
Reply from leoj99
Dec.05.2012
12:38AM EDT
|
 |
Quote: "Quote: "I can see that it seems you are very clever. Illumination is there is light or you can see the light. If you can see the light I think that is the same as being aware or even awakening. Consciousness is nothing but your conditioning. So once you see this conditioning there is illumination, awareness, awakening...
" .........
Illumination and awareness are not the same. Don't confuse the two ... hahaha " ......... So can you please enlighten us why it is not the same...?
|
|
|
 |
→Quote & Reply
→Post Reply
148340
|
 |
| |
 |
|
Reply from Sam Hardy
Dec.05.2012
06:17AM EDT
→Email Sam Hardy
|
 |
Do not follow the ideas of others, but
learn to listen to the voice within yourself.
Dogen
Great advice but could be dangerous is you're a schizophrenic.
|
|
|
 |
→Quote & Reply
→Post Reply
148346
|
 |
| |
 |
|
Reply from Sam Hardy
Dec.05.2012
06:41AM EDT
→Email Sam Hardy
|
 |
‘If you understand, things
are just as they are; if you do not understand, things are just as they are.’ (currently at the no. 5 spot in the Squidoo Proverbs and sayings chart).
Either way is spirit. What do we have to worry about?
|
|
|
 |
→Quote & Reply
→Post Reply
148347
|
 |
| |
 |
|
Reply from Sam Hardy
Dec.05.2012
06:43AM EDT
→Email Sam Hardy
|
 |
Correction: Great advice but could be dangerous if you're a schizophrenic. |
|
|
 |
→Quote & Reply
→Post Reply
148348
|
 |
| |
 |
|
Reply from Sam Hardy
Dec.05.2012
10:14AM EDT
→Email Sam Hardy
|
 |
Quote: "Quote: "Quote: "I can see that it seems you are very clever. Illumination is there is light or you can see the light. If you can see the light I think that is the same as being aware or even awakening. Consciousness is nothing but your conditioning. So once you see this conditioning there is illumination, awareness, awakening...
" .........
Whether you see
that it seems or it seems that you see,
It’s ‘all one’
what you think you see in me. :)
|
|
|
 |
→Quote & Reply
→Post Reply
148351
|
 |
| |
 |
|
Reply from Avisitor
Dec.05.2012
10:40AM EDT
→Email Avisitor
|
 |
Quote: "Quote: "Quote: "I can see that it seems you are very clever. Illumination is there is light or you can see the light. If you can see the light I think that is the same as being aware or even awakening. Consciousness is nothing but your conditioning. So once you see this conditioning there is illumination, awareness, awakening...
" .........
Illumination and awareness are not the same. Don't confuse the two ... hahaha " ......... So can you please enlighten us why it is not the same...? " .........
When I was growing up, my older brother would tell me things and I would ask why. His answer would always be "that's for me to know and for you to find out". I would always be pissed at that. Later, I understood the meaning and would still wonder why I had to wait. Being impatient and wanting everything now ... a lesson is learned in the meanwhile. So, my answer to you ... even if you can not accept it ... is ... that's for me to know and for you to find out .... hahaha
|
|
|
 |
→Quote & Reply
→Post Reply
148352
|
 |
| |
 |
|
Reply from leoj99
Dec.05.2012
11:20AM EDT
|
 |
So since you don't want to enlighten us I always think they are the same. |
|
|
 |
→Quote & Reply
→Post Reply
148355
|
 |
| |
 |
|
Reply from Sam Hardy
Dec.05.2012
12:36PM EDT
→Email Sam Hardy
|
 |
Consciousness is nothing but your conditioning.
Anyone who can make a statement like
that has already gone way beyond enlightenment.
If it weren’t so profoundly
spiritually and cognitively, and even experientially, mistaken, not to mention incomprehensible,
it might almost make me angry. lol.
|
|
|
 |
→Quote & Reply
→Post Reply
148359
|
 |
| |
 |
|
Reply from sit_teh
Dec.05.2012
03:26PM EDT
→Email sit_teh
|
 |
Truly an Unconditioning |
|
|
 |
→Quote & Reply
→Post Reply
148361
|
 |
| |
 |
|
Reply from sit_teh
Dec.05.2012
03:37PM EDT
→Email sit_teh
|
 |
The root has come before the flower, always. That being the unconditioning (experience) comes before the enlightenment (subject). |
|
|
 |
→Quote & Reply
→Post Reply
148362
|
 |
| |
 |
|
Reply from sit_teh
Dec.05.2012
03:44PM EDT
→Email sit_teh
|
 |
Health |
|
|
 |
→Quote & Reply
→Post Reply
148363
|
 |
| |
 |
|
Reply from leoj99
Dec.06.2012
12:26AM EDT
|
 |
Quote: "
Consciousness is nothing but your conditioning.
Anyone who can make a statement like
that has already gone way beyond enlightenment.
If it weren’t so profoundly
spiritually and cognitively, and even experientially, mistaken, not to mention incomprehensible,
it might almost make me angry. lol.
" .........
So what do you think?
Like the statement ... the universe is conscious or the universal consciousness.. how did people know that there is universal consciousness...?
|
|
|
 |
→Quote & Reply
→Post Reply
148371
|
 |
| |
| ←Back To Topic List |
|
↑Go to Top of Page |